Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Pride and Prejudice Post #3

Read the following prompt. Then answer the question that follows. It deals with the final chapter of this section, Volume 2, of your required reading this week 2/16.


"Why, do you think, is it hard for people to admit their mistakes in judging others?" Think about your own experiences with this and add briefly to this, then think about this question: "Do you see any parallels between your own personal experiences and those of Elizabeth?"

Think specifically about everything Elizabeth has gone through up to this point, especially in this next section of reading.

REMEMBER TO POST ONE ORIGINAL POST AND THEN FOLLOW-UP POST FOR FULL TEN POINTS!! DUE SUNDAY AT MIDNIGHT-2/22/09.

33 comments:

  1. I can realte to Elizabeth's experience because i to have had an opinion of someone like she had for Mr. Darcy. As an example of my doing this I did the same thing when i meet some of the cheerleaders. i've always been under the impression that cheerleaders are frankly stuck up b***hes. after i've hung out with many of the cheerleaders from this school my opinion has changed towards them. now i think they are all almost fun smart sweet girls and no longer think they're snobs. i feel it's hard to admitt you are wrong in judging someone cause no one likes to be wrong. their pride gets in the way and they don't want to change their opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  2. i think its human nature to take the offensive as soon as proven wrong. fire against fire in a way. the normal inclination of hearing something against what you think is to resist it.

    i can see a parallel in that i once, like Elizabeth, had a very strong opinion of someone i knew, and was very convinced of it. being able to accept my being wrong was difficult

    ReplyDelete
  3. I believe that i can relate somewhat to Elizabeth's experience of mistakenly misjudging others. Everyone does judge someone at first glance even though it is wrong. As for Elizabeth she labeled Darcy as a rude, stuck up, prideful man who would never be a gentleman. She never got to learn who he truly is. I have done that with a few too many people, such as a new kid in school. I have judged them before i knew them. After i got to know them and talk to them, I realized they are actually a fun loving, outgoing person. No one wants to admit they judged, especially me, but if you do admit you won't feel like you did something wrong and hurtful.

    ReplyDelete
  4. i agree with SidW in "their pride gets in the way and they don't want to change their opinion." often a persons pride comes before hearing another's opinion

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with Eli because he said it is human nature to be offended if you are proven wrong. You have to get over that fact that you were wrong and resist what you hear unless you know its the truth.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think that a lot of people show prejudice in their everyday lives. I myself can relate to elizabeth because I have also held belief against a person before I really got to know them. I myself have had a tendecy to judge a person by their political beliefs, but i have learned that a persons beliefs in politics dorsnt mark their character. Elizabeth thinks at the start that darcy is a rude arrogant jerk, but she has to admit that her prejudice feelings towards darcy are wrong. Just like in real life, it's hard for people to admit their mistakes, which is why people won't admit when they have shown prejudice towards another person.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree with Eli that it is human nature to take offense towards someone before you even get to know them. Alot of people live their lives on the defense towards everyone around them. I think that if we could teach society to look at people and think positively instead of defensively, we would have alot less drama, issues and hatred towards one another.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think that everyone has misjudged someone before they really got to know the person. Sometimes it's out of jealousy, sometimes stereotypes and sometimes looks. I know that I have done this before and found that in the end, the person really was not what I thought they were. As for Elizabeth, she misjudged Darcy. She thought he was a stuck up, rich man that had too much pride and would never be a gentleman. As the book progresses, I think that her feelings will change and she will realize what Darcy really is like. Even though I believe that first impressions are very important, I have done the same thing before...and I usually regret my first thoughts if the person turns out different.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I 100% agree with what Brittany said about it being hard for people to admit/accept their mistakes. Because it's hard to admit that you did something wrong, you usually "committ the same crime". I have always believed that until you accept your mistakes, you will keep making them. Hopefully, Elizabeth will realize that she was prejudice towards Darcy and accept it.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I can relate to the way Elizabeth acted in judging others. I have judged people many times by what I have heard from other people about them and I formed an opinion of them without ever talking to them. I have been wrong in my judgements before and some of the people that I formed a negative opinion of have turned out to be some of my best friends once I got to know their true self. I think that it is hard for people to admit that they are wrong because we live in a society where we feel it is important to be right all of the time.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I agree with Brittany M with what she said about how we don't like to admit that we have made a mistake. Many people will just stick to their first opinion even if they don't truly believe that opinion anymore because they don't want to admit that they have made a mistake. Many people feel that they have failed at something if they have made a mistake so they try and act as though it was not a mistake instead of doing the right thing and trying to correct it.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think it's hard for people to admit mistakes to others because it indicates weakness in their judgment, and nobody likes being seen as weak. I can relate to Elizabeth's experiences in misjudgement because I have often been surprised by people's behavior, even when I thought I knew someone well.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I agree with Eli about people being resistive to acquiescing to a new viewpoint. The lengths to which the average person will go to avoid changing their views are stunning.

    ReplyDelete
  14. i think its hard for people to admit their mistakes in judging others because no one likes to be wrong especially when it becomes blantantly obvious you were wrong.
    i have had a problem like elizabeth before where i really hated someone for reasons i can't even remember now. and now, were friends and do sports together. SAYDE! it was hard for me to admit i was wrong back then but now it just seems silly

    ReplyDelete
  15. i believe that it is hard to admit mistakes in judging others because the judgement was formed by the opinion one gets from studying another person. if that opinion is viewed as wrong the person who formed that opinion will take the accusation of being judgemental personally and most everyone finds it hard to reshape the way they judge a person.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Eli, i think, is exactly right, "i think its human nature to take the offensive as soon as proven wrong." Even when we know were wrong its hard to admit so and we automatically take the offensive.

    ReplyDelete
  17. i do see a connection between elizabeth and myself because i have made wrong interpretations about someone and been forced to see that my opinion was wrong and that i had judged that person before knowing what they were really like.

    I agree with Eli when he says that its just in human nature to take offense in someone before getting to know them. a lot of people i know are always on the defensive toward others that they dont really know.

    ReplyDelete
  18. In my belief, no one can come out of a situation without any opinion. If forced to pick a side, people resort to the safest and best bet and stick to it unless something large has influenced a change. On adding to personal story, I judge people from the first couple times I meet them and I feel that my first instict is always right> Elis a professional bloger.\

    ReplyDelete
  19. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I agree with Eli... its so beautiful. im actaully going to agree with Kali because people have a really hard time admitting defeat. Everyone judges, chooses a side and sticks with it just to keep a strong side. Jill and Thad used to hate eachother..like back in the day...no joke it was REAAALLY funny

    ReplyDelete
  21. The only reason I can think of why people don't like to admit their mistakes of judging people is because they are too prideful or rude or don't care enough to take it back.

    (by the way, i think Eli might be a professional blogger)

    AND yes it is easy to judge someone wrongly, like Elizabeth, but for me it was easy to admit i was mistaken.

    Thad and i are cool now, by the way.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I agree with Eli. it is human nature to judge people within seconds of meeting them. i like judging people, its fun for me. like, i used to judge Jill, alot.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I Ethan Moulder from the depths of insanity would like to say that it is hard for people to admit their mistakes in judging others just because they dont want to be guilty in being wrong. This seems to be true in my good friends who always think they are right. I feel like my friends should be preachers because they are good at convincing people that they are right even when they might not be. I can relate to Elizabeth because i like her, (i....like her, not i LIKE her because i dont like her i think she is dumb)seem to place opinions on people and judje them before i get to know them. For example... the first time i laid eyes on my second grade teacher, i thought she would be an old witch. It turns out that this wasn't the case.

    ReplyDelete
  24. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  25. i must disagree with the opinion that humans are naturally meant to judge others, i think that in this age of snap decisions judgment has been integrated into our society. i must admit however that i have judged rightly and wrongly over the length of my life. the judgments were snap decisions upon our first meeting, and sometimes it was hard to reverse the decision and others it was not. Elizabeth judged Darcy on the things she heard about him and the way he behaved on there first meeting.

    ReplyDelete
  26. i do agree with every one who said that the reason no one wants to change there judgments because they then will be proven wrong, and nobody likes to be proven wrong even if they were.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I agree with Jill when she says that people are to rude or pridefull to take back their feelings. i also agree with tara when she says that when people are taking a side, they usually stand strong and dont change sides.

    P.S. "Hard work never killed anybody, but why take a chance?"

    ReplyDelete
  28. people don't want to admit that they are wrong. everyone strives to be perfect. no one likes not being right. elizabeth judges someone and is wrong. i believe this happens to almost everyone. you cant be perfect, right?

    ReplyDelete
  29. i agree with jill about eli. also she says that for some people it is easy but for others its harder

    ReplyDelete
  30. Most people have a hard time saying that they are wrong. When they fist see a new person they judge that person and what they think of that person is what usally sticks. It might even stick for a long time and might not change because that person cant admit that they are wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  31. I agree with Brittany and how people judge people before they really know that person. They go by what they heard or what they see. And it might even be a better world if no one did this

    ReplyDelete
  32. Like everyone including Elizabeth, ive judged a lot of people without knowing them plenty of times. & even though i try not to, lots of times, i still do it. And i think it has to do with the way weve been tought by society, judging people by what a person looks like or their background info such as ethnicity, etc. & most of the times we are complete wrong about what we though of that certain person. Yet it takes us awhile to admit we were wrong because, NO ONE ever likes to admit they are wrong, specially me. So maybe, eventually Elizabeth will realize that Darcy is not so shallow and rude, and that there really is someone in there she just might like more than she thinks.

    ReplyDelete
  33. i completely agree with jessica and eli on this one. it is reaally hard to admit when youre wrong, and it does have to do with that thing called...pride. & also like what jessica said: "until you accept your mistakes, you will keep making them". Its true, if we dont admit to doing wrong, well only keep blinding ourselves and keep making the same mistake, such as judging others by their cover.

    ReplyDelete