Think about the following questions:
"Do you think that Frankenstein went too far in his quest for knowledge? Did he have a
good motive for his project? Did he have adequate knowledge to begin his project? Did he
consider possible consequences of his actions?" (Frankenstein Study Guide, Mcgraw-Hill, n.d., p. 19).
Respond, thinking about what you have read so far, in regards to why Frankenstein invented the monster, what is motives were, and how it protrays his overall charateristics as a human. Please be sure to respond first the questions above and comment on someone elses post!
* I have thoroughly enjoyed reading your responses back and forth. Very well done!*
Tuesday, February 10, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I don't think Frankenstein went too far on his quest because he was very curious about his experiment and overall he had a good motive. His motive was good because he didn't want to do anything to hurt anyone he was just wanting to further learn the unexplored. He should've thought all the possibilities out before he began such a dangerous project because it didn't seem like he knew what he was getting himself into.
ReplyDeleteYes Frankenstein went too far in his quest for knowledge. He not only risked his own life he also put others at risk. Although he had a good motive, he wanted to benefit mankind but in this process he created a monster and this has come back to haunt him.
ReplyDeleteI agree with jenna that his motives were good, but he did take it too far. I agree that he should have thought this through, but his quest for knomledge went the wrong way.
ReplyDeleteI think that he didnt go too far in his search for knolage but he didnt go far enought in his precautions. I think he had a good motive for his creation. He planned on his creation to be humanlike and not want it to hurt anyone. I think that beacuse he created life that he had enough knolage. i think that he did not take enough precations.
ReplyDeleteI agree with frodo because he did risk others lives and his quest did take a turn for the worse
ReplyDeleteIn the quest for knowledge nothing is ever too far, if you don't try something how are you going to know anything. Even given the new information about how bad stuff happened after the creation of his monster I still don't think it would be a bad thing to retry. As the common phrase goes you have to break a few eggs to make an omelette. How else are you going to know. This is how scientific break throughs happen, by people taking risks. If the wright brothers considered the risks to airplanes were and how they could crash and decided not to tryout their design we wouldn't have airplanes today, consider that. it may be a great risk but it can turn into great achievement. Just the motive of searching for knowledge is great enough for me.
ReplyDeleteI don't think Frankenstein went too far with his knowledge because he is very capable of doing a lot with what he already knows. Especially because he comes from a very educated family and believed in who are now known to us as famous philosophers. I guess his only motivation was curiosity. He was very curious of what he was able to do. I don't think he neccesarly thought about any consequences because he was so into finding out what he could do.
ReplyDeleteI suppose that i agree with Alex but, partially. Yes. he did put others at risk but, its not like he knew exactly what was going to happen.
ReplyDeleteFrankenstein did not go to far on his quest for knowledge he just did not take the right percausions for creating something that big. His motive was pure he wanted to be able to test something sciientifically which is legitimite. He completed his project so he had the right knowledge, but he did not have the right percuasions. I do not think that Frankenstein thought about the consiquince of his actions.
ReplyDeleteI belive with the majority and say he should have thought about his actions and what will happen better.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Alex J. because he had the same view as myself. He didn't take it too far but he definitely should've thought out what was gonig to happen
ReplyDeleteHe did not go too far. He had had questions about life and about raising the dead and he was willing to put effort into answering his questions. He may not have expected it to be so creepy, but at the same time there was no way for him to know. And he shouldn't be too disappointed because he did try something that he wanted to see if he could do and he did it. His motive was something that every young person, or even anyone, could be, just to see if it was possible and to answer some of their questions. He did have the knowledge because he had been studying science ever sense he was very little. I don't think he really did consider a lot of the consequences, but I think he was so anxious that he really didn't care.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Clancy, sense he did accomplish making his creature, he obviously had most of the knowledge there. He was just so excited for finishing this and seeing if it could be done, that he really was thinking about any of the negative out come there could have been.
ReplyDeleteYa I agree with this as well, because if he did not have enough knowledge he could not have completed his creature and in turn there would never have been a problem so it is not a question of whether or not he had enough knowledge
ReplyDeleteYes he did go to far. He should have studied the outcome a little bit more possibly. He risked his life as well as others. I know he didnt mean to create a monster but he still did. He should have destroyed it right after he created it cause he new what he had made was a scary thing.
ReplyDeletei agree with what "froto" said because he did have good motives...they just didnt go his wayy
ReplyDeleteI do think that he went to far in his quest for knowledge. He didn't know what he was getting into. I don't think he expected the outcome. He had no motive of creating the beast except to prove he could do it.
ReplyDeleteI agree with stefanie that he risked his life and the life of others and that he didn't mean to create a monster. Victor didn't plan for what would happen if it worked
ReplyDeleteI agree with froto I dont think he did go too far for his quest. You could almost say its his responsibility to do so since it is his creation. He was motivated because it was his experiement and he was curtious to see what else he could learn from it.
ReplyDeleteI believe that the quest for knowledge is never-ending. Frankestein could only go too far if he himself had become a killer, instead he made a creature that had naturally fatal tennencies. The creature's actions were the creature's not Frankenstein's. However, one must take into account that Frankestein feels responsable for his creation, a noble and rather selfless action.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I do believe that the good Victor Frankestein did not know what hewas getting into with this project, and as such he paniced when he should have remained calm and fled when he should have taught. Had he had more faith in his creation, he could have brought his quest for knowledge to an all time high and become the premier scientist of his field.
I do however agree with Franky in that Frankenstein's project was reckless and dangurous to himself and others, and should have been preformed in a controled environment.
ReplyDelete