"Frankenstein Study Guide". Retrieved 29 January 2009. McGraw Hill .
"Urged by her husband, Percy Shelley, to expand her ghost story into a novel, Mary Shelley
added Walton’s letters as a frame to Frankenstein’s tale. Do you believe the letters are an effective device for drawing readers into the story. What did you learn about explorers through
Walton’s letters? What did you learn about the stranger? Why do you think Shelley chose to
lead into the stranger’s story by starting with a frame story about Robert Walton? " (P. 15)
FRANK GROUPS: Respond to the questions above. Be complete in your thoughts, provide EXAMPLES from the text. Remember, TWO posts for the full ten points. Due: February 8th, 2009 at midnight.
Sunday, February 1, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Even though It says on a sheet of paper I assume that you want us to post our answers up here.
ReplyDeleteFirst of all I learned that the explorers are trying to reach the North Pole and that they are on a boat. The Boat tends to get stuck in the Ice as the weather cools and warms. I think this is in effect tells us that they are in a very very rural environment with no human beings within hundreds of miles. As we know Alaska and anywhere above the arctic circle is a harsh environment. So to find a person floating on a piece of ice is strange, and Mr. Walton must have been very surprised to have found him.
We lean that the stranger is indeed a strange individual. It seems weird that when asked to come aboard the stranger wants to know where they are going. And it was even more baffling when the captain to him, to the north pole, he seemed content. There is something different about this man because any other person, after going through an ordeal like that would have wanted to go back to civilization. Mr. Walton also found this suspicious as he told Margret in his letter "if you had seen this man who thus capitulated for his safety your surprise would have been boundless." It was also very interesting that the man was worried about the other man on the sledge that they had seen before, the man whom he called demon and whom he was trying to pursue.
The author probably wanted to open the story like this because she wanted to give the story a little more mystery. If the the man who is telling it is a mysterious person then the story itself would be even more freaky.
The first three letters I feel did not have much to do with drawing me in as much as the last one. So to answer the first question, in general, no I don't think they were needed to draw the reader into the story. It could probably just opened into the story.
nice work, u got an A+
DeleteSo, personally, i think these whole letter things was just a horrible idea. If i want to be hooked into a story, im gonna see some madness, chaos, and maybe even some explicit content. if they would just throw me into the story already i would be happy to read the rest. I didnt learn much about the stranger, because the letters held no interest with me. Shelley probably used these letters to make the story a bit more authentic, a bold move yes, but poorly done.
ReplyDeleteI consider this reply as an opinion than more of a proper response to this question
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe letters to me confused me more than they helped at first but than later on as i read they seemd to help understand the story a bit better.They explained to me that they were traveling to the north pole and than they find victor and helped him out.
ReplyDeleteI agree with jake and Wog, jake had a good point about trowing the story out their is just better but wog had a much better sence of the story than pninn because his made better sence of the story of events
ReplyDeleteI would have to say that the letters at first were a bit confusing. Knowing that the other used a lot of her personal background in the story, only got me more confused. So, to me the letters would'nt be an effective device to get my attention in this case.
ReplyDeleteWell, i found out that Walton was in search for the source of magnetism in the polar reginons and while being at sea he found the perfect friend he was looking for. "I never saw a more interesting creature: his eyes have genereally an expression of wildness, and even madness, but there are moments when, if anyone performs an act of kindness towards him....."(pg.10) I also learned that the "stranger" has common things with Walton they are both kind and interested in Science. Again, I think that Shelley started out with the story about Robert Walton because it also showed some of her personal background.
Id have to agree with Jake K. I believe that no one really thought that the whole letter format draws very much attention. It was'nt horrible. It just did'nt catch my attention thats all.
ReplyDeleteOverall, the letters were confusing when I first started, but by the end they became more helpful. I liked her idea because especially in the 4th letter I wanted to know who the "stranger" was and what he had to do with anything. So personally the letters hooked me.
ReplyDeleteI basically learned that the explorers were traveling by boat to the North Pole to research where humans have never been before. I learned that the "stranger" was on the search for something that had apparently, "fled" from him.
She probably introduced Robert before the stranger because he is probably going to be narrating the story so it was a good way to tie everything in.
I agree with Irving's first post, because the letters were confusing at first but then cleared up by the end.
ReplyDeleteThe letters really hoocked me into the story. they made the story feel more real and the letters slowly got more interesting, witch was a great way to start the story. the letters layed out the story, i found out that the explorers were going to the North pole, were Robert Walton runs into The Stranger. I lerned that the stranger is alot like Robert the they become friends.
ReplyDeleteI think that the letters give a understanding of walton and his life that if you had started the story in the beginin he would have been a stranger also. But it does make the story alot more boring. This means that it is an not an effictave device. The letters pushed readers away and made it so that you didnt want to read the book. you learn that they are going to the north pole to discover the undescovered.
ReplyDeleteYou do not learn much about the stranger until chapter one starts. I think that Shelley chose to start the story how she did because it gives the reader good understanding about walton.
I dont agree withe Irving, I thought the letters were a great hook and bulit up in a way that got me ready for the story.
ReplyDeleteI agree with DoowkrikEkaj because the letters were verry boring and it would be a better read if you threw us into the strangers story in the first place. It would hook alot more people that way.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteok personally i was bored reading those letters and couldnt pay attention and thot it was a dumb way to "hook the reader in". tho yes the letters give good info and gave u a background of what was going on but they could have come later in the book after a better intro into the story.
ReplyDeleteI think Shelly started with introducing walton first just as a different way of writing the sotry. which was different and a good way to change up things but i didnt like how she did it.
And i didnt learn much about the stranger other than he was a guy trapped in the ice.
I think it was a good idea for Percy Shelley to add those letters. It made me have a better idea for what he was doing at the beginning of the story and why. I didnt really learn ALOT about the explorers except for that they were doing the same thing as Walton was. It did make me learn alot of about Victor (the stranger) and it was nice to really understand how they meet. It gave off a good way of introducing him as the main character and helped give us a feeling of what Victor was like. I think it was a great idea for Percy to add that introduction to help introduce the story its self and give a good feeling before the ghost story but it also did foreshadow a little.
ReplyDelete=)
i agree with DoowkrikEkaj when the story should have stated with some action lol it would have drawn me in and i prob could keep up with the reading assighnments easier
ReplyDeleteI have to disagree with leah because i thought it was a great way to introduce the story. It would have bored me with a introduction of thinking and writeing letters probably made the introduction shorter and summed it up faster
ReplyDeleteI didn't understand the first few letters, i had to read them all twice and then i caught the jist of what was happening. They were weird but kind of a good way to start the story. I think she put too much useless stuff in the letters and she should of just got to the important part.
ReplyDeleteI agree with leah that she agreed with doowkirkekaj that the story should of started with more action. The last letter had some action but the other letters were pretty dull
ReplyDeleteYes I think that the letters were a good way to get readers interested in the story.
ReplyDeleteThrough out the letters that walton wrote I learned that Walton is a sad lonely man that wants knowledge and a friend. They are searching for information on why the north pole is magnatized.
The stranger is searching for a "demon" that has escaped and is travelling through the artic.
Shelley decided to lead in with the letters because it helps the reader understand more about what is going on through out the book.
I disagree with Frankie, Leah and doowkirkekaj, because i feel that Shelley starting with the letters was a good idea leading up to the action.
ReplyDeleteI am noticing that people either think it is a good to have the letters or bad and those that think it is good think that the first three letters done fit. I do think that the letters were good But I didn't really follow the first three so they ment nothing to me. Overall not understanding the letters did not hook me in.
ReplyDeleteI believe that the letters are a creative technique. Most stories only have one narrator through out the book, but this makes it so that we can hear the voice of someone else. It was a nice way to introduce Victor and get to know him a little bit and get to know Walton and see what they were each doing and see what they were about before the story really began.
ReplyDeleteI don't think that people didn't understand the letters because of the fact that they were letters, but because of the writing. I think that some of my fellow classmates should be open to the fact that Mary Shelley was using a different technique and that just because the writing wasn't the easiest to understand, that it wasn't a good idea. Even when Victor starts to narrate, its not that simple to follow, but this is before our time and most of the writing back then was like this. Sometimes you just have to read a page more than once before you understand it.
ReplyDeleteSo, I learned that explorers are determinend to do,and sacrifice
ReplyDeletemany things to achieve their goals, but they have some fears and trials on their ways to be successful,to accomplish their wills.
I learned that the stranger is persevering to achieve his goals,
after everything he passed through he still wants to keep seeking for
the unknown answers, he is also quite weird.
I think Mary Shelley wants to compare the two characters,
compare their story and also their thirst and seek for science knowledge.
I also agree with Desi, in my case,i had to re-read some parts of the letters to get in to it, to understand what was happening ,not just because im an exchange student , but because its not that easy to understand and keep pace if we don't get focus on it.
ReplyDeleteI particularly liked the letters, i think its a good idea to hook the readers,
well, maybe because I had to check at my dictionary some words, and that made me interested on the story. haha..
I think that the question we must all ask ourselves is: Why not use this as a lead up to the real story?
ReplyDeleteThe story would honestly have an increadably boring start if Shelly did not use the letters, for one we would probubly not know who was actually telling the story without it.
without this opening set of letters, the story would make no real sence. However during this introduction, as Peter said, we learn that the explorers are travleing to the north pole with a true blue lust for knowledge. We then learn that the stranger honestly does not care where he ends up, so long as he finds the "demon" first.
The Demon is described as: "a being which had the shape of a man, but apparently of gigantic stature," this is obviously the Fankenstein Monster, because everyone knows that the Monster is freakishly large.
Anyway, this was an interesting opening to a book to me, it has the vastness of adventure and the suspence of mystery. without this opening, it would have been quite an opening slog to get into the book
I agree with lais in that the letters were used to compare the two men, Frankenstein and Walton.
ReplyDeletehi
ReplyDeleteyoo we both here just like decade after lmao
Delete